Painful Truth: Simpler just to re-write history

History is fascinating, and frustrating. If you read a simple history book, you often get a simple story. X came before Y, and was followed by Z. A better book will often admit that they aren’t sure about X, don’t know exactly where Y happened, and that there is some debate over whether Z was as important as previously thought.

This is where you get historical conspiracy theories, ideas that radically re-write history to scratch that itch at the back of the mind caused by doubt.

Take the Phantom Time Hypothesis, which has been kicking around since the late 1990s, mostly in Europe.

Heribert Illig is a German scholar who believes that almost 300 years of European history was made up as part of a conspiracy by Holy Roman Emperor Otto III. Among other things, he thinks Otto invented Charlemagne to make himself look better.

This theory would eliminate the years 614 to 911 AD from the historical record entirely.

As pretty much every working historian to look at the theory points out, this causes some problems. Among other things, it causes a time-skip that wipes out most of the Saxon kingdoms in England, as well as Alfred the Great and most of the Viking invasions. It eliminates the birth, rise, and spread of Islam across the Middle East, North Africa, and Spain, pretty much the entire Tang Dynasty in China, a couple of dozen Byzantine emperors, the rise and fall of the Tibetan Empire, and so forth.

When it comes to how so much history could have been added into the calendar, Illig essentially believes that events outside Europe were dated wrongly in comparison to his timeline (strange that none of them noticed) or that within Europe, events and characters across a broad swathe of 300 years and multiple nations were simply fabricated. Jesuits and Cabbalistic numbers are, of course, involved.

Illig was inspired by Immanuel Velikovsky, a psychologist who had earlier re-written history based on an even more odd idea – he thought that planets had knocked around in the Solar System, bringing random catastrophe to Earth in the historic past. He thought Venus had been spat out of Jupiter like a watermelon seed, and that Mars had later wandered in close to Earth as well. His ideas deny everything we know about physics going back at least to Newton.

Velikovsky’s theories are only slightly more outlandish than those of 19th century American politician Ignatius L. Donnelly, who believed that Atlantis was a scientifically advanced ancient society wiped out by a natural catastrophe – he’s the one who introduced this common idea into our pop culture, so we at least have him to thank for Aquaman. 

Off to one side is Gavin Menzies, who claimed that the Chinese Treasure Fleets of the 1400s travelled further than believed (plausible) that they discovered North America (dubious) and finally that they made it all the way to Venice, where the Italians cribbed Chinese ideas to kickstart the entire Renaissance (nope).

Made up history isn’t more exciting than real history. Real history does have comets and conspiracies and mad tyrants and love stories and heroes. But it is messy. It doesn’t make much sense as a story, with a nice neat ending or a single explanation for everything.

That’s where these re-written histories find their origin. They impose more order than history naturally contains. 

Rather than saying that there’s a lot we still don’t know, a lot we may never know, they give us the comforting and false sense that the world makes sense.

Just Posted

PHOTOS: Slippery roads didn’t deter runners in the 11th annual Fort Langley marathon

Most registered runners and walkers still came out, despite ice from an overnight snowfall.

Langley street named after the late Hugh Davis

The street is near the family homestead that’s still a working farm.

Vancouver Giants fall with only 10 second left against Victoria

A Langley hockey team dropped a 4-3 game on the Island, before returing home to play Red Deer today.

Freezing temperatures expected in Lower Mainland

Snowfall warning ends, but surge or icy air to continue

Ball hockey fundraiser to honour Langley man lost to cancer

Annual tournament at UBC aims to raise $45,000 this year

Langley welcomes the Year of the Dog

The Live in Langley Chinese Association Lunar New Year gala was a feast for the senses.

VIDEO: Protesters rally for affordable housing ahead of B.C. budget

Residents call on province to keep locals housed

Update: Highway 97C reopened following multi-vehicle incident

Highway 97C is closed to eastbound traffic near Pennask Summit following an incident Sunday afternon

#Metoo movement causing confusion in many men, fear of missteps with women: experts

Being painted by the same sweeping brush as those alleged to have mistreated women has angered men

Liberals to dig deeper, aim higher on gender equality in 2018 federal budget

Finance Minister Bill Morneau said the budget would include measures to boost women in the workforce

Late-winter snow storm blankets Lower Mainland

Some areas got up to half a foot of snow

Body of missing skier found

Man’s truck found in Revelstoke Mountain Resort’s parking lot covered in ‘several days’ snow’

Most Read