Painful Truth: Consequences hard in panopticon world

How does society judge the people whose beliefs are so odious that they demand action?

If someone tells you they didn’t vote for the party you prefer, you probably wouldn’t punch them in the face.

But what if they told you they voted for a fringe party you particularly despise?

What if they said they don’t believe in voting at all? Maybe they believe that all mainstream politicians are dupes of a conspiracy of extradimensional lizard people, or that women shouldn’t vote, or that the vote should be restricted to only white property owners?

Could you get along with them? Should you try?

Should you just punch them in the face?

(Morally, I think it’s fine to punch Nazis. A bloody nose is the least they’ve got coming, karmically speaking, for their desire to oppress and murder millions. Practically, Nazi-punching might get you arrested, so use your own judgment.)

Here we get into the difficult bit. Nazis are garbage people. Obviously racist and misogynist and homophobic twits? Not going to be on my Christmas card list, and I’m going to avoid dealing with them, personally or commercially, whenever I have that option.

So we have a shared, and variable, level of tolerance. We can have friends and work with people across party and religious lines. That is for the best! It allows us to change and grow together, to exchange ideas without exchanging gunfire.

But there’s another division, emerging from the fact that we always have a circle of tolerance.

Some of the biggest clashes we’re having right now aren’t between people with different beliefs, they’re about how we enforce those circles on the people who step outside them.

A woman in Alberta went on a racist screed in public in a restaurant. Whatever “the mainstream” looks like in Canada is going to condemn her behaviour.

She’s since lost her job.

I say that’s fine. She embarrassed the heck out of her employer, who was probably frantic to disassociate the business from her odious words and actions.

Maybe you disagree. Maybe you think that woman’s firing was fine, but there were other situations where a firing wasn’t warranted.

I’m not arguing here that we shouldn’t have consequences (see above re: Nazis deserve a fist-full of knuckles).

I’m saying that the debate over the appropriate consequences is only going to get more intense.

Twenty years ago, that woman in Alberta would still have her job, because no one would have filmed it. Back then, if you left your hometown, and acted like an awful, awful person, the chances you’d face any blowback were minimal. You could walk away from your crappy, racist behaviour and go back to your everyday life.

Now, we put our lives online. We can film anything, anywhere.

We live within a near-perfect panopticon, one we built for ourselves out of camera phones and Facebook shares and viral tweets.

So every day, you can see a story of someone doing something awful. And every day, we get to have the debate over consequences again.

I have no idea where it will end. I fear, not that we will go too far, but that we won’t go far enough. I worry that we’ll get tired of it all, and allow some of the worst people in the world a little more latitude in their speech, and in their ability to spread their vile ideas.

Just Posted

Aldergrove celebrates 18th Extreme Home Repair: VIDEO

‘Big Reveal’ marks 15 years and 18 home repairs by Acts of Kindness volunteer team

Everyone invited to Extreme Home Repair ‘reveal’ in Langley Monday

A block party with bouncy castles and treats begins at the Adam’s home on 32A Avenue at 4:30 p.m.

Cloverdale Rodeo finishes with thousands in prizes, Will Senger memorial

Overall, more than 21,000 people came to the rodeo over the four days

2018 Cloverdale Rodeo and Country Fair Round-up

Looking back on the community events, rodeo and country fair that took place over May long weekend

VIDEO: Flames destroy abandon Langley home Monday

Fire ripped through a single-storey house in Brookswood on the holiday Monday.

VIDEO: After the floods, comes the cleanup as Grand Forks rebuilds

Business owners in downtown wonder how long it will take for things to go back to normal

Rachel Notley to skip premiers conference to focus on pipeline deal

Kinder Morgan has ceased all non-essential spending on the Trans Mountain pipeline project until it receives assurances

B.C. tech company will power Uber Elevate

Moli and Uber announce research and development partnership.

UPDATE: Woman dies in ocean accident near Tofino hours before daughter’s wedding

“We are so thankful to everyone who helped our mom.”

Olympian sues USA Swimming, saying it failed to protect her

Ariana Kukors Smith alleges her former coach Sean Hutchison began grooming her for sexual abuse at the age of 13

Defence minister thanks troops for B.C. flood relief work

Harjit Sajjan says not only was military response quick, support from locals has been ‘tremendous’

McPhee in boxing spotlight

‘Turmoil on 200th’ Pro Am Boxing event at Langley Events Centre

Fraser Valley Symphony ends 34th season

‘Romantic Rendezvous’ features Michelle Mares on piano on June 2

‘Find Your Fit’ at Aldergrove career event

Students and general community sessions set for Aldergrove Secondary

Most Read