Odd Thoughts: Ownership has its privileges

We live in a strange world in which parents are allowed to abuse their children in some ways, but other forms of abuse will not be tolerated within the social and legal order.

It comes from a foggy understanding of the concept of ownership.

Do parents own their children, or not?

The first laws against child abuse grew out of a social intolerance for the treatment of animals. There were laws against animal abuse before there was legal recognition of child abuse. Indeed, in some jurisdictions, laws against cruelty to animals were invoked to protect children, including from their own parents.

(Similarly, those same laws were invoked to protect women from exceptional abuse from their husbands. A little abuse was okay, but guys who went overboard were frowned upon – the vestiges of which attitude continue to haunt us, and result in a continued alarming number of domestic assaults and deaths to this day.)

Some people are currently struggling with the conviction of two parents who provided inadequate care for their sick child. The child died of meningitis while the parents, who are now awaiting sentencing that could see them jailed for up to five years, insisted on sticking to the voodoo of naturopathy, a practice of alternative “medicine.”

Meanwhile, the provincial government is crowing about its plan to vaccinate all Grade 9 students with a four-strain meningitis vaccine, a significant improvement over the current single-strain preventative.

All of B.C.s Grade 9 students will be vaccinated against those four strains of meningitis, that is, except for those whose anti-vaxxer parents exempt them from the program – something that they can do with the law’s blessing.

Does anyone else see the irony in this?

Parents can be thrown in jail for denying their child appropriate protection against the ravages of a potentially fatal disease, while other parents have the full legal right to deny their property – er, I mean, children – appropriate protection against the ravages of the same potentially fatal disease.

Is it only illegal when a child dies?

What happens if – or when – a child denied the protection of the province’s new four-strain vaccination course dies of one of those four strains? Will the anti-vaxxer parents then be prosecuted for neglect of their duty to protect their children?

Do we really have to wait until a child dies to find out?

How about the anti-vaxxers whose children may die of measles? Or whooping cough? Or diphtheria? Or any of the other “minor” childhood diseases that have become minor only because of extensive and effective vaccination programs in this country and others?

In light of the recent conviction, should anti-vaxxer parents be prosecuted for pain and suffering of an infected child – before another one dies?


Just Posted

Another snowfall warning for Lower Mainland

Another 5-10 cm expected for Metro Vancouver, Fraser Valley and Sunshine Coast

Painful Truth: Why did Andrew Scheer speak at an event with a white nationalist?

Appearing at the same event as Faith Goldy shows Scheer’s judgment is lacking.

Langley baseball team brings aid to Puerto Rico

Blaze raised $50,000 for the trip to

Fraser Valley Thunderbirds bound for playoffs

Minor midget team of mostly Langley players secures spot over Family Day weekend

Langley chamber joins call to kill ‘no pipeline ever’ law

Bill C-69 will hurt the local Langley economy, Chamber warns

New report calls for regulated heroin sales to curb B.C.’s overdose problem

B.C. Centre on Substance Use points to organized crime and money-laundering as contributing factors

Millennial men least likely to have a family doctor: Statistics Canada

Report found more women have primary care physicians, compared with men

VIDEO: North Delta elementary school closed following stabbing that left cop, woman in serious condition

An off-duty police officer and a woman were injured outside of the school Wednesday afternoon

70% of Canadians agree with mandatory vaccines for children: poll

The debate for pro and anti vaccinations has heated up after a measles outbreak in Vancouver

VIDEO: Woman, off-duty cop in serious condition after stabbing outside B.C. elementary school

The officer was interceding in an alleged assault when he and the woman were stabbed

5 to start your day

Two people are in critical condition after stabbing, searchers recover body of missing snowshoer and more

Most Read