Letter: Writer defends TWU stance on law school


Dear Editor,

In response to Mr. Jang’s diatribe [Earlier court ruling misused, June 9 Letters, www.langleyadvance.com] against Mr. Kuhn’s interpretation of the 2001 TWU v BC College of Teacher’s Supreme Court of Canada decision [Langley university fighting Ontario and Nova Scotia, May 6, Langley Advance], I felt compelled to come to Mr. Kuhn’s defence of his quite correct legal analysis of that decision.

In that decision, the Supreme Court didn’t confine its reason’s to a technical nature as to the standard of review, but delved into the issue of balancing the two seemingly conflicting constitutional right to equality as well as freedom of religion.

A quote from the headnotes of that decision is illuminating: “Absent concrete evidence that training teachers at TWU fosters discrimination in the public schools of B.C., the freedom of individuals to adhere to certain religious beliefs while at TWU should be respected. Acting on those beliefs, however, is a different matter. If a teacher in the public school system engages in discriminatory conduct, that teacher can be subject to disciplinary proceedings before the BCCT. In this way, the scope of the freedom of religion and equality rights that have come into conflict can be circumscribed and thereby reconciled.”

The Law Society of BC received legal opinions from some of the brightest legal minds in B.C., who came to the same conclusion as Mr. Kuhn, which was why the Benchers of the law society approved the TWU law school.

In short, when dealing with constitutional rights, we must remember that they exist to protect from the tyranny of the majority. That is why freedom of expression doesn’t protect “nice” speech, it exists to protect offensive speech.

Similarly, freedom of religion doesn’t mean that everyone is entitled to their own religion so long as they keep it to themselves and never act on their religious beliefs. If that were the case, freedom of religion becomes a powerless right.

Freedom of religion in this case shields TWU and allows those attending to adhere to a code of conduct that accords with their Christian beliefs, and not be sanctioned (by being denied accreditation) for adhering to their religious beliefs.

Witty statements such as “they have the right to their religious beliefs, but not the right to be accredited as a law school” completely miss the point.

I suggest Mr. Jang could use some legal education – TWU perhaps?

Eric Vandergriendt, Aldergrove

Just Posted

Make-A-Wish BC grants Langley girl’s wish

Mae Ten Haaf battled a brain tumour much of her young life, and recently returned from Disney World.

Mark Warawa won’t run in the next election

Langley MP issues a statement about his impending retirement from politics.

Giants defenceman Bowen Byram named WHL On the Run Player of the Week

Registered three goals and three assists in a pair of victories for Langley-based team

British wheels have a certain appeal

Langley Area Mostly British Motoring Club celebrates English auto design

LETTER: Langley resident says a cancer plague is building

A Langley City man believes a poor diet and unhealed emotions are part of his cancer journey.

UK lawmakers reject Brexit deal in 432-202 vote

House of Commons votes against the deal struck between Britain’s government and the EU

Millennial Money: Don’t let Instagram envy get you into debt

A full 48 per cent of U.S. households have credit card debt

Jury debates fate of man accused of killing 12-year-old B.C. girl 40 years ago

Police allege Garry Handlen told a cop how he abducted, sexually assaulted and strangled Monica Jack in May 1978

Letters on way to all homeowners in B.C. speculation tax communities

Property owners have to register to avoid vacant-home tax

New orca calf in Salish Sea ‘healthy and active’

Birth cause for celebration but things still dire genetically, expert says

Good Samaritan rescues cat found in heaps of garbage at B.C. landfill

The cat was abandoned and left to die at the Foothills Boulevard Regional Landfill, the BC SPCA says

Vancouver, Victoria, Kelowna home to Canada’s most expensive rentals: report

According to PadMapper, units in larger B.C. cities cost $1,300 to more than $3,000

Former MP Svend Robinson wants to return to politics

Robinson is expected to be acclaimed as the NDP candidate in the riding of Burnaby North-Seymour

Most Read