Letter: Measure tar sands before deaths

Dear Editor,

While I also respect anyone’s right to hold an obverse or unpalatable opinion, Terry Brenan [Oil sands next to tundra anyway, Feb. 11 Letters, Langley Advance] yet again misses the mark with his uninformed, incomplete response to my reponse  [Surviving LNG tanker proves nothing, Feb. 4 Letters, Advance] to his letter [Tankers proving safe for LNG, Jan. 7 Letters, Langley Advance].

Not to mention his all-hat, no-cattle, one-sided view of the situation, the fact that the tar sands are built in an uninhabitable swamp is even more offensive, but I am glad he brought it up.

Swamps are among the most fragile, important, and un-restorable elements of our ecosystem, and the fact that we don’t live in them is beyond irrelevant.

You can ask David Suzuki about that. He built his entire career on it.

But what does he know, compared to an armchair quarterback who apparently visited Fort McMurray and knows for a fact that what comes out of a smokestack is steam? I’ll be the first to let him breathe it.

And since when does the word “pristine” not apply to a swamp?

Comparing the loss of life at Bhopal in mere casualty numbers is another crass example of the exact source of our problem: our mentality. Counting bodies like dollars and writing them off as collateral damage is not something we need to be faced with in Canada.

And waiting until the big one happens is also about as intelligent as thinking it never will. Look how many accidents we’ve had in Canada just in the past year.

Just because it hasn’t happened yet in Alberta demonstrates the mentality that started this argument.

Imagine if the Calgary flood had washed through the swamp. That was just a shot across our bow, and it would have rendered thousands of hectares useless for growing crops, permanently.

Only a few people died in that one, but it still cost billions. The only difference there was that most of it was repairable, and mostly measurable in dollars.

It shouldn’t take 10,000 people dying to prove my point, or that nobody died to prove his.

No, I have not spent time in the Fort McMurray area. And who would want to? I wouldn’t want to be down wind or downriver anywhere near that hot mess.

But one does not need to go there to cite the scientific research that we have. I didn’t run the tests, certified scientists did, and they presented their findings in a movie that was screened at the Kwantlen College campus right here in Langley.

If one ever attended or led any of the many environmental and pipeline meetings or protest rallies organized by groups like Pipe-Up or Lead Now that occur regularly in Langley, then one could also find themselves accurately informed.

It takes several times the energy to cook the petroleum out of the tar sands that it used to, most of that as natural gas, which involves fracking, another very unpopular concept.

And if anyone thinks an oil fire burns hot, wait until we get an LNG tanker or pipeline explosion on film.

I wonder what Mr. Brenan will say when China wrecks their last two usable rivers and wants to come here for ours. There is already a drought in California.

All I know is, they aren’t going to be drinking my Great Lakes one bottle at a time.

Danny A. Halmo, Langley

Just Posted

ODD THOUGHTS: Hi, I’m Bob and I’m a news addict

It’s dangerous to be a news junkie is this day and age.

Team BC advancing undefeated in junior nationals

A Langley-based team is 6-0, thus far, at the Canadian curling championships.

Langley serves as backdrop to pair of competing short films

In the 20th annual Crazy8s Film competition, two of six producers will be filming in Langley.

VIDEO: Rivermen back on the ice in Langley tonight

In their game against West Kelowna tonight, Langley’s junior A hockey team gets into action at 7:15.

Louder helicopter partly to blame for rash of complaints in Surrey: RCMP

Police say helicopter training is conducted in Cloverdale because it’s ‘a very practical area where we do a lot of real police work’

VIDEO: Here’s what the B.C. legislature officers are accused of buying

Personal trips, purchases, alcohol and more laid out in 76-page report by Plecas

B.C. Green Party leader calls for Assistant Deputy Speaker to step aside

Weaver alleges whistleblower was fired after looking into the Liberal MLA’s expenses

B.C. man says he was evicted due to ‘personal vendetta’ against his toddler

Matt Astifan says he has tried to do what he can but a young child will always make some noise

Case of B.C. man caught with 27,500 fentanyl pills thrown out due to Charter breach

‘Ambiguous’ signal by drug sniffer dog Doodz leads to B.C. Supreme Court decision

B.C. animal killer Kayla Bourque guilty of breaching conditions

Bourque is expected to be sentenced on Feb. 8

Men allegedly tied to Red Scorpions gang arrested in B.C. drug busts

Nanaimo RCMP have made multiple arrests and seized drugs, weapons and cash

VIDEO: Soon-to-be-extinct caribou moved to B.C. interior

The three caribou are being held in pens north of Revelstoke

Man pulls over to help injured owl, gets hit by SUV

Chase RCMP say owl flew away while they were on scene

Most Read