Debbie Anderson outside the Chilliwack Law Courts after her trial wrapped up July 6. Anderson is charged with evading taxes and fraud for teaching others that paying income taxes is optional. (Paul Henderson/ The Progress)

Trial ends for Chilliwack woman involved in elaborate tax evasion scheme

So-called ‘natural person’ theory repeatedly rejected by the courts

The trial of a Chilliwack woman who followed the “natural person” theory to avoid paying income tax, while counselling others to do the same, wrapped up in BC Supreme Court on Thursday.

Debbie Arlene Anderson followed renowned tax cheat Russell Porisky and his Paradigm Education Group, which taught that income tax is optional for individuals who declare themselves natural persons. This, so goes the theory, is opposed to the legal (artificial) person working for pay under a contract of service.

The argument behind Porisky’s scheme has been repeatedly rejected by the courts, which have said his teachings are nothing more than counselling illegal tax evasion.

Porisky himself was sentenced on July 29, 2016 to four years in jail and fined $260,000. His partner Elaine Gould was sentenced to one day in jail and was fined $38,242. The duo’s fraudulent counselling to more than 800 students resulted in an estimated $11 million in income tax evasion.

Anderson faced four counts in her trial, which wrapped up July 6 in BC Supreme Court in Chilliwack. Two under the Income Tax Act (ITA) were for making false T1 statements by not declaring taxable income of $113,276 for 2005 and 2006, and evading $22,689 in taxes by failing to report income for 2005, 2006 and 2007. She also failed to remit $12,337 in GST in contravention of the Excise Tax Act.

Anderson also faced one count of fraud over $5,000 under the criminal code.

The court hear there was a specific program created by the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) to investigate Porisky and his followers called Operation Fable.

During her closing submissions in court Thursday, Anderson, who defended herself, had various arguments beyond the “natural person” theory, including that the ITA is so complicated that no one individual can understand it.

But her main argument remained true to the natural person theory, specifically that income tax only applies to what she repeatedly called “office holders.”

“Income tax is a tax on the privilege of being a holder of an office in the federal jurisdiction only,” Anderson said, reading from 84 pages of closing submissions.

“I receive money as my private property not as public property.”

She argued that the CRA cannot force private persons into becoming office holders for whom it is mandatory to pay tax on income.

“The created, the government, cannot be greater than the creator, people,” Anderson concluded.

During Crown submissions it was explained that, quite simply, a person cannot simply decide whether money they are paid constitutes taxable income. People can legally structure their financial affairs in various ways to minimize taxes payable, but tax evasion is tax evasion.

Another Porisky follower, Michael Spencer Millar, who also represented himself, was sentenced Feb. 28 to two-and-a-half years in jail for following the debunked theory.

Justice Neill Brown is scheduled to render a decision in the Anderson case Nov. 3.

 

Debbie Anderson outside the Chilliwack Law Courts after her trial wrapped up July 6. Anderson is charged with evading taxes and fraud for teaching others that paying income taxes is optional. (Paul Henderson/ The Progress)

Just Posted

Milner actor taps into inner jokester for Langley Players comedy

The curtain goes up on The Foreigners next Thursday at the Langley Playhouse.

ON GARDENING IN LANGLEY: Ice storm caused damage to many trees

Advance columnist Pam Erikson suggestions tips for minimize winter damage and prepping for spring.

Coach’s Corner: Big games coming for dominant Giants

The Vancouver Giants will face two tough tests after a series of victories.

Police investigating after car torched in West Abbotsford

Vehicle set ablaze early Wednesday morning

Dinos put the bite on TWU in basketball action

Home games didn’t go terribly well for the Trinity squads.

Solitary-confinement veto a chance to address mental health: advocate

B.C. Supreme Court made the landmark ruling Wednesday

Winter storm coming to B.C. this weekend

The bets are on as to how much snow the province will actually get in the coming days

B.C. civil rights group files complaint about RCMP arrest of man who later died

Dale Culver, a 35-year-old Indigenous man was arrested in Prince George last July

Lawyer says former B.C. government aide ‘barely guilty’ in ethnic vote scandal

Brian Bonney pleaded guilty to a breach of trust charge

Quite a few tears as homemade quilts distributed to residents of Ashcroft Reserve, Boston Flats affected by last summer’s fire

Quilters in B.C. and Alberta worked through the summer and fall to create more than 100 quilts.

Teachers’ union votes for non-confidence in school board

Lack of action after embattled trustee’s comments created unsafe workplace, Chilliwack teachers claim

Island Health: No need for alarm in wake of Victoria needle-prick incidents

Three incidents in a week prompts meeting between health authority, city service providers

B.C. coast loggers celebrate history, hope for improvement

Truck Loggers Association awaits B.C. NDP government’s new direction

Global Affairs aware of report of two Canadians kidnapped in Nigeria

The foreigners were heading south from Kafanchan to Abuja when they were ambushed around Kagarko

Most Read