RCMP appeals finding of egregious harassment against sergeant

RCMP appeals finding of egregious harassment

TORONTO — A ruling that senior RCMP officers mercilessly harassed a sergeant after deciding he had lied about his run for political office should be set aside as flawed, the federal government said Thursday.

In its notice of appeal, Department of Justice lawyers argue Ontario Superior Court Justice Mary Vallee made numerous mistakes, including forcing RCMP Commissioner Bob Paulson to testify, and relying on evidence from a confidential informant.

“The trial judge made errors of laws and palpable and overriding errors of fact in finding that the conduct of the (RCMP) was outrageous,” the notice states.

The notice also takes issue with Vallee’s assessment of the credibility of various witnesses.

At trial, Sgt. Peter Merrifield, who joined the RCMP in 1998, testified his superiors waged a seven-year campaign to damage his reputation that included punitive transfers and unfounded criminal accusations after he took part in a federal Conservative nomination meeting in Barrie, Ont., in 2005. Merrifield testified that one superior, Supt. Marc Proulx, was critical of various Conservative policies on the firearms registry and the definition of marriage.

Someone also leaked confidential and damaging information about him to the media.

The father of three, who said he had been upfront about his political views and activities, sued Proulx, Insp. James Jagoe, and the RCMP. He said he had been forced to take medical leaves to deal with depression and the stress of the situation.

In awarding Merrifield $141,000 for his mistreatment, Vallee denounced the RCMP’s conduct as flagrant and egregious.

“The defendants had a reckless disregard of causing the plaintiff to suffer emotional distress. His emotional distress was severe,” Vallee wrote in her 174-page decision. “The defendants’ outrageous conduct was the actual and proximate cause of the plaintiff’s emotional distress.”

Merrifield’s lawyer, John Phillips, expressed disappointment that the RCMP and government were appealing in light of the “very strong and supportive findings” Vallee made.

“The appeal is going to be vigorously defended,” Phillips said in an interview.

The lawyer also said he would be seeking “substantial” costs from the government for “wasting public funds to continue the harassment of a very decorated officer of the RCMP.”

The Justice Department, however, argues in its appeal notice that Vallee was wrong to find the government, Jagoe and Proulx liable for a new “tort of harassment” or that the defendants had deliberately harassed the sergeant or had a “reckless disregard” for the distress they caused him.

The appeal notice also asserts that Paulson was ordered to testify even though he had no relevant evidence to give.

Paulson testified at trial that he had been led to believe Merrifield was a disgruntled employee whose accusations against his superiors were groundless. The defence also painted Merrifield as an unreliable and untrustworthy witness.

Vallee, however, found him credible and said Proulx’s decision to move Merrifield out of national security work was “unjustified and punitive” and resulted in a “permanent stain” on his reputation and career.

She also concluded Proulx ordered an audit of Merrifield’s credit card expenses in 2012 without asking for an explanation or offering specifics at about the time the RCMP knew of a substantiated allegation that the superintendent had procured a prostitute — misconduct Merrifield had complained to Paulson about.

It’s not clear when Ontario’s top court will hear the appeal.

Colin Perkel, The Canadian Press

Just Posted

Langley School District Foundation volunteers tackle wrapping projects of all sizes, shapes

This year’s wrap money goes to food and homeless initiatives.

Cold nights mean homeless turned away from Langley shelter

The Gateway of Hope shelter has had send some people to other shelters as they ran out of room.

Crown appeals stay against Jamie Bacon in Surrey Six killings

B.C.’s prosecution service says judge’s decision reveals ‘errors of law’

Many turn out for Langley neighbourhood celebration

The second annual Brookswood Night of Lights on Dec. 8 kicked off the holiday season.

Langley RCMP seek man wanted for drug charges

David Main was last seen living in Langley City.

VIDEO: Hundreds line up at Langley farm for pancakes and a chance to help

The 14th annual Krause Berry Farm breakfast with Santa raised almost $4,700.

Liberal Hogg wins South Surrey-White Rock byelection over Conservative Findlay

B.C. riding to be represented by non-conservative for first time in decades

Six-year-old boy needs $19,000 a month to treat rare form of arthritis

Mother of sick Sooke boy asks government to help fund treatments

Environmental groups slam NDP decision to continue with Site C

Construction industry, meanwhile, is cautiously optimistic about how the project will look

Be ladder safe both at work and home

WorkSafeBC wants you to keep safe while hanging those Christmas lights this year

B.C. overdose deaths surpass 1,200

96 people died of illicit drug overdoses in October

Feds agree to give provinces 75 per cent of pot tax revenues

Finance Minister Bill Morneau announced the agreement today

Red Scorpion associates cuffed in drug-trafficking bust

Kamloops RCMP lay charges in connection to Red Scorpion drug trafficking ring

BC Ferries adds extra sailings for Christmas

More than 175 sailings are being added, including 130 between the Lower Mainland and Vancouver Island

Most Read