Couple who killed four family members sued by former lawyer over legal fees

Shafia and wife sued by former lawyer

A couple convicted of killing their three teenage daughters and another family member are being sued by the woman’s former lawyer, who alleges he is owed nearly $135,000 in legal fees.

John David Crowe alleges Mohammad Shafia and his wife Tooba Yahya “have failed, refused or neglected to make any payment whatsoever” to clear Yahya’s outstanding legal bills in the five years since their trial ended, save for one cheque shortly after their conviction.

In his statement of claim, Crowe says Shafia had agreed to pay his wife’s legal costs and had previously made several payments by cheque.

But the couple argues in their statement of defence that Shafia made no such arrangement, and say Yahya’s bills were paid off with a $20,000 cheque in February 2012.

The lawsuit is being heard in a Kingston, Ont., court this week. 

The pair were found guilty in 2012 of four counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of daughters Zainab, 19, Sahar, 17, and Geeti, 13, and Shafia’s first wife in a polygamous marriage, 52-year-old Rona Amir Mohammad.

Their son, Hamed, was also convicted of the same offences but is not a target of the lawsuit.

Aside from the legal fees he alleges he is owed, Crowe is also seeking nearly $9,000 in interest. In his claim, the lawyer says bills were to be paid on receipt with interest set to kick 30 days later at a rate of five per cent annually.

Crowe alleges he has “repeatedly requested payment” but received nothing after the February 2012 cheque.

Yahya, meanwhile, says in court documents that the lawyer told her at the end of the trial that only $20,000 was left on her tab, which was paid a month later.

A short while later, Crowe gave her a statement of accounts that showed her balance owing was close to $67,000, which was “inconsistent” with the amount given verbally, she says.

She also alleges Crowe’s hourly rate fluctuated significantly throughout the statement of account he provided, ranging from $350 to $450 at various times.

Yahya argues the amount claimed by the lawyer is “excessive, grossly exaggerated and should be assessed by the court.”

Though Shafia acknowledges he helped pay his wife’s legal bills, he denies ever making “any verbal or written agreement” to do so.

Both are seeking to have the suit dismissed and their costs reimbursed. Yahya is also asking the court to assess the lawyer’s billing.

Shafia, Yahya and Hamed have been in custody since their arrests on July 22, 2009, and will have to spend at least 25 years from that date behind bars before they can apply for full parole.

Their bid for a new trial was quashed late last year after Ontario’s top court ruled among other things that expert evidence on so-called honour killings had been properly admitted at their trial and the son was properly tried as an adult.

The victims’ bodies were found on June 30, 2009, in a car at the bottom of the Rideau Canal in Kingston, Ont.

The Crown at the trial asserted the murders were committed after the girls “shamed” the family by dating and acting out, and Amir Mohammad was simply disposed of.

Paola Loriggio, The Canadian Press

Just Posted

Crown appeals stay against Jamie Bacon in Surrey Six killings

B.C.’s prosecution service says judge’s decision reveals ‘errors of law’

Many turn out for Langley neighbourhood celebration

The second annual Brookswood Night of Lights on Dec. 8 kicked off the holiday season.

Langley RCMP seek man wanted for drug charges

David Main was last seen living in Langley City.

Surrey RCMP search for man who allegedly robbed Cloverdale store at knifepoint

Surrey RCMP release photos taken from surveillance video in November robbery.

Pellet gun prompts Langley RCMP to respond

A report of a firearm drew a large number of officers to Langley City.

VIDEO: Hundreds line up at Langley farm for pancakes and a chance to help

The 14th annual Krause Berry Farm breakfast with Santa raised almost $4,700.

B.C. overdose deaths surpass 1,200

96 people died of illicit drug overdoses in October

Feds agree to give provinces 75 per cent of pot tax revenues

Finance Minister Bill Morneau announced the agreement today

Red Scorpion associates cuffed in drug-trafficking bust

Kamloops RCMP lay charges in connection to Red Scorpion drug trafficking ring

BC Ferries adds extra sailings for Christmas

More than 175 sailings are being added, including 130 between the Lower Mainland and Vancouver Island

Emergency response ‘well executed’ in B.C. carbon monoxide poisoning

Emergency Health Services talks about how first responders dealt with this ‘mass casualty event’

Aldergrove Elks support Youth Soccer Club

Aldergrove Youth Soccer got another boost as the Aldergrove Elks presented cash donation to the club

Otter Co-op funds wetlands project

Otter Co-Op helps Abbotsford Mission Nature Club build $90,000 wildlife viewing platform

WestJet Christmas video turns children’s wishes into reality

This year’s annual video took a new spin on the 12 days of Christmas

Most Read